Talk:Raye Penber

big mistake
There's also a big mistake to be noticed in the animé version: once Penber holds the paper sheets from the Death Note, as he writes the names of his fellow detectives on them, he didn't see the Shikigami former owner (Ryuk) and therefore never received the rules from him, just like the same rules command (as the audience was told from the episode with the drug-addict thief that tried to kidnap the bus, an saw Ryuk immediately after touching a piece of paper from the Death Note; or when Ryuk explained to Light before that, that he should be careful with the Death Note, because if his family touched it they would be able to see the Shinigami as well). Such detail was very upsetting for the fans because of its inconsistency, which opposes to the claim of the so called "high elaborated" congruence of the whole Death Note story.

This passage is confusing at parts, as well as holding a biased tone due to a lack of possible explanations. I was unaware that this detail was "very upsetting" to fans for "inconsistency," and I am a fan of Death Note, myself. Is there someone who can correct this in such a way to do it justice? --れび (talk to Lavi!) 01:08, 14 April 2009 (UTC)

If you notice in the anime, Penber doesn't actually touch the death note pages. The pages are clearly covered with cardboard with spaces cut out where the names are to be written in. So his hands only touch the cardboard. Agentxyz (talk) 22:14, March 23, 2014 (UTC)

Is it relevant?
To mention that Raye can go to neither Heaven nor Hell, because he has used the note?

Sooooo....
wouldn't Raye be a Kira too? an unknown Kira?

He was never called "Kira" by anyone. 24.246.89.144 17:13, June 26, 2012 (UTC)

FBI deaths
did raye think of their face in his mind when writing his fellow agents name in death note because light did not instruct him 2

Yes he did, he told him to write down the names while he focused on their photos. He essentialy made him do it inadvertantly.

Human death note user
I added him to the category "human death note user" because he's human and he used a death note. Someone has reverted the edit. I'm un-reverting the edit, as it is correct. 24.246.89.144 17:13, June 26, 2012 (UTC)

I reverted the edit because Penber was not an actual death note “User”. That category is only for humans that used the death note with the intention of actually killing people. Penber was forced to write names and never knew what would actually happen. I have reverted your edit again but thanks for trying to contribute to the wiki :) - Kira4real 21:47, June 26, 2012 (UTC)