Category talk:Death Note Top 10 Heroes

Subjective and very opinionated
I understand the justification of putting theories in this wiki, but this is by no means a theory. This ranking is just one user's opinion of which Death Note character is the most evil. I was okay with keeping the "heroes" and "villians" category, but honestly, this is a bit too much. In this wiki, we should aim to be objective, meaning we use cold hard facts as much as possible. If this ranking was the most commonly accepted by members of the Death Note fanbase, I would advocate for its stay on this wiki- but its not. Its left better on a talk page or even a forum Mikami Teru 20:54, August 21, 2011 (UTC)

And by no means does L even consider himself a hero. In the manga, he claims he does cases only out of interest and not out of justice as usually he claims. The second rewrite anime special paints a darker side of L, with L even calling himself a monster.

L has manipulated and lied to people only to further his goals similar to Light. Remember when he let Lind L. Taylor die in his place? Despite Lind being a criminal set to be executed, the fact that L used Lind as a guinea pig does not make him better than Kira- Soichiro even remarks that in the films.

L is probably not evil, but he is by no means perfect. And he is definately not the "top hero" of this series.

Mikami Teru 20:58, August 21, 2011 (UTC)

I disapprove of the creation of this as well. This is indeed just one user's opinion of which Death Note character is the most good, in many other people’s opinions Light Yagami is a hero instead of a Villain. I will remove this page soon but first I’ll give people some time to defend it’s being here first... Kira4real 01:57, August 22, 2011 (UTC)